PLT Masthead 430

Masthead Education - Litigation

Council "did not have vires to lease part of common to pre-school nursery"

The London Borough of Wandsworth did not have the vires to lease premises situated on a common to a private pre-school operator, the Court of Appeal has ruled.

In Muir, R (On the Application Of) v Smart Pre-Schools Ltd [2018] EWCA Civ 1035 the Court upheld a High Court ruling in favour of Alexander Keay Muir, who had made a competing proposal for use of the premises.

Wandsworth had decided to lease the site to Smart Pre-Schools.

Floyd LJ said the case turned on the correct construction and application of the Ministry of Housing and Local Government Provisional Order Confirmation (Greater London Parks and Open Spaces) Act 1967.

He noted this gave a local authority the power “in any open space” to provide and maintain: “indoor facilities for any form of recreation whatsoever" and “centres and other facilities (whether indoor or open air) for use of clubs, societies or organisations whose objects or activities are wholly or mainly of a recreational, social or educational character”.

Wandsworth had argued that the pre-school proposals came within either of both of these categories.

Mrs Justice Lang in the High Court had ruled that leasing the premises to a private fee-paying nursery would not provide “facilities for public recreation” since the public would not have a right of access and facilities would only be provided for children enrolled in the nursery.

Giving judgment on Wandsworth’s appeal, Floyd LJ said: “The proposed facility is more in the nature of a school than a recreational facility.”

He noted it would offer all-day child care for pre-school children, which was not “recreation” and “the contrary view, that [it] is a predominantly recreational facility with ancillary educational and child care facilities is, to my mind, not a natural or appropriate way of describing what is proposed”.

The judge also said that a limited company running a pre-school could not be described as a club or society as meant by the Act.

Mark Smulian

Page Sponsor - A&M Bacon

Archive

Search more than 10,000 articles

Featured Jobs

Newsletter Subscription

* indicates required
Choose Newsletter(s) (tick all that apply)
 

Featured Events

Fixed term tenancies - Cornerstone Barristers

London

CPD Hours3 FeeEarly Bird offer £30+VAT (Until 1st October) / Standard Ticket £40 +VAT VenueCornerstone Barristers, 2-3 Gray's Inn Square, London, WC1R 5JH More details to follow...
→ View listing
Succession & assignment of tenancies - Cornerstone Barristers

London

CPD Hours3 FeeEarly Bird offer £30+VAT (Until 1st August) / Standard Ticket £40 +VAT VenueCornerstone Barristers, 2-3 Gray's Inn Square, London, WC1R 5JH More details to follow...
→ View listing
Local Authorities – Planning Seminar Series 2018: Leeds - No5 Chambers

Yorkshire

No5 Barristers' Chambers Planning Group invites you to join them at their Local Authorities Seminar Series which is taking place in London, Bristol, Leicester and Leeds. The Seminars consist of a morning session dedicated to Planning and Development Update...
→ View listing
Local Authorities – Planning Seminar Series 2018: Leicester - No5 Chambers

East Midlands

No5 Barristers' Chambers Planning Group invites you to join them at their Local Authorities Seminar Series which is taking place in London, Bristol, Leicester and Leeds. The Seminars consist of a morning session dedicated to Planning and Development Update...
→ View listing
Commercial property: CRAR and forfeiture of lease - High Court Enforcement

Distance Learning

Cost: Free-of-charge This webinar will cover commercial property and forfeiture of lease and is intended for those in the commercial property sector and property solicitors.  
→ View listing
HB Editorial Services Ltd 2016.